Technical Review by
Craig MacAlpine
Email archiving solutions create tamper-proof, searchable copies of all email communications — meeting regulatory retention requirements, supporting eDiscovery and legal hold, and providing disaster recovery for email data. Email archiving is a compliance requirement in most regulated industries. We reviewed the top platforms and found TitanHQ Email Archiving, powered by CyberSentriq, Intradyn, and Barracuda Cloud Archiving Service to be the strongest on search performance and eDiscovery workflow depth.
Businesses of all sizes rely on email to communicate both internally and externally. Your business will likely send out hundreds of emails a day, and storing these safely is a key concern for compliance, legal, and operational reasons.
To help you find the right product, here is our list of the top email archiving platforms for businesses. We’ll discuss their features, strengths, and what kind of business they are best suited for.
Best Email Archiving Solutions For Business Shortlist
TitanHQ, now powered by CyberSentriq, offers a cloud-based archiving solution (also known as ArcTitan) focused on compliance and long-term retention. We think it works well for mid-sized organisations and MSPs managing multiple tenants who need affordable, compliant archiving.
ArcTitan captures messages automatically and stores them in encrypted, tamper-proof format. Search speeds are strong, pulling specific emails from years of data in seconds. Unlimited storage with no fees for departed employees removes capacity planning concerns. The admin console scales well for MSPs and multi-tenant environments.
Customers mention competitive pricing and straightforward setup. Support teams get positive marks for responsiveness during onboarding. The unlimited storage model is consistently highlighted as a differentiator. Something to be aware of is that the Outlook add-in can be tricky to mass deploy, and advanced configuration for complex enterprise retention scenarios is limited.
We think TitanHQ works well for mid-sized organisations and MSPs managing multiple tenants who need affordable, compliant archiving. If you need basic retention with strong search and competitive pricing, ArcTitan delivers.
Intradyn is an archiving and eDiscovery platform that captures email, Teams chats, SMS, and social media from a single interface. We think it works well if your compliance requirements extend beyond email into Teams and social channels.
Intradyn captures messages in real time via standard protocols while also grabbing Teams conversations and social media content. Everything feeds into a single searchable index. eDiscovery supports 100+ languages with proximity search and legal hold. The standalone architecture lets you change security vendors without migration. Unlimited AWS storage with per-user or per-department retention policies is included. A free crawler tool handles historical data migration.
Customers praise the straightforward interface and responsive support team. The standalone architecture gets positive mentions since you can switch security vendors without migrating your archive. Something to be aware of is that social media content archives in email format rather than native layouts, and occasional gaps in social media capture require periodic monitoring.
We think Intradyn works well if your compliance requirements extend beyond email into Teams and social channels. The unified search across content types is a real time-saver for legal and compliance teams.
Barracuda Cloud Archiving Service is a cloud-native archiving platform bundled into Barracuda’s broader Email Protection suite. Barracuda offers archiving as part of a bundle alongside their Email Secure Gateway and Email Encryption, making it a good option for small to mid-sized businesses looking for a single vendor to cover security and archiving together. We think it is best suited for organisations already running Barracuda for email security or backup.
Automatic archiving captures every message with customisable retention policies. The fully indexed archive supports eDiscovery with filtering by date, sender, recipient, and keyword. Unlimited per-user storage removes capacity planning concerns. The Outlook Add-In with local cache provides offline archive access. End-user archive access via the M365 plugin reduces help desk requests.
Customers praise fast retrieval and straightforward setup. Support gets high marks, particularly for legal teams running frequent searches. Something to be aware of is that the admin interface feels dated compared to newer solutions, and the search syntax has quirks requiring training.
We think Barracuda makes sense if you are already running Barracuda for email security or backup. The unified management reduces complexity, and the bundled pricing keeps costs predictable for smaller teams.
Global Relay Archive targets heavily regulated industries needing to archive communications across 50+ platforms. The vendor serves 22 of the top 25 global banks and is a strong fit for organisations where compliance failures carry serious consequences. Global Relay’s service goes beyond just email, capturing instant messaging, social media, and voice communications. One thing to be aware of is that leaving this service can be expensive, as you will need to export large amounts of data. However, Global Relay offers a fully managed migration service to help with this. We think Global Relay fits organisations where compliance failures carry serious consequences.
Global Relay covers an impressive range of regulatory frameworks: SEC, FINRA, HIPAA, GDPR, and MiFID II. The platform archives email, instant messaging, social media, voice, and file sharing with immutable storage and per-item encryption. AI-powered conversation reconstruction supports eDiscovery investigations. Corporate directory integration tracks organisational changes automatically.
Customers praise the search and analytics capabilities. Support teams get strong marks for hands-on help during migrations. Government and financial services customers highlight the regulatory coverage as a key differentiator. Something to be aware of is that there is a steep learning curve with complex onboarding, and pricing is cost-prohibitive for smaller organisations.
We think Global Relay fits organisations where compliance failures carry serious consequences. If you are in financial services, healthcare, or government, the regulatory coverage and immutable storage are difficult to match elsewhere.
Libraesva Email Archiver offers both cloud and on-premises deployment with flexible storage options including local disks, network shares, and S3-compatible storage. We think it works well for organisations already using Libraesva products or MSPs building a multi-tenant archiving practice.
AES 256-bit encryption with certified time-stamping handles GDPR compliance requirements. The Outlook Add-In lets users access archived mail without a separate portal. Multi-tenant architecture with full API supports MSP deployments. Over 80 distinct access permissions with a Privacy Officer role provide fine-grained control. Flexible storage options let you choose between local, network, or cloud storage.
Customers highlight the fast interface and powerful search capabilities. Organisations handling high email volumes appreciate the quick indexing. Something to be aware of is that market recognition is limited compared to larger archiving vendors, and the platform delivers best value when paired with other Libraesva security products.
We think Libraesva works well for organisations already using Libraesva products or MSPs building a multi-tenant archiving practice. The storage flexibility and on-premises option make it a strong fit for organisations with specific data residency requirements.
Microsoft offers a cloud-based archiving solution for businesses. Being part of Microsoft 365 and Exchange, this product is easy to use and implement. Microsoft Exchange Online Archiving is the native archiving solution built into the Microsoft 365 platform, making it the path of least resistance for M365 environments with straightforward email archiving needs. It is an ideal platform for smaller companies who need basic email archiving that is cost-effective and easy to set up. We think Exchange Online Archiving works well for M365 environments with straightforward archiving needs.
Users access their archive mailbox directly within Outlook and can search or restore deleted emails without IT involvement. Customisable retention policies and auto-expanding archive capacity are available in M365 E3 and E5 plans. The platform is included in many M365 plans with no separate licensing cost. Native Outlook integration means there are no additional tools required. The archive reduces primary mailbox load while maintaining search and availability.
Customers praise how easily the archive reduces primary mailbox load while maintaining availability. Users create subfolders and categorise archived mail, which makes retrieval straightforward. Something to be aware of is that the platform is limited to email archiving with no coverage for Teams, SMS, or social media, and eDiscovery and compliance features are less advanced than dedicated platforms.
We think Exchange Online Archiving works well for M365 environments with straightforward email archiving needs. If you are managing mailbox sizes and need basic retention without a separate platform, it delivers. For multi-channel archiving or advanced eDiscovery, a dedicated platform will go further.
Mimecast Cloud Archive provides cloud archiving for email and Microsoft Teams as part of its broader security platform. Mimecast stores all email data on its own servers, with quick search times and ease of use, even on mobile. This is a popular choice among clients who value being able to search and access their archive from anywhere. We think Mimecast works best for enterprises already using Mimecast’s email security.
Mimecast captures one-to-one, group, and channel Teams conversations alongside traditional email, archiving metadata like send time, device, and user identity. End-user self-service search via the Outlook plugin or web portal reduces IT support burden. Compliance scanning flags potential regulatory risks. Recent AI-driven search and sentiment analysis features extend the platform’s capabilities.
Customers praise the automatic archiving that runs without ongoing effort. End users search their own archives via the Outlook plugin or web portal, which reduces the load on IT. Something to be aware of is that the admin console feels clunky and slow, and initial migration of historical archives requires significant effort.
We think Mimecast works best for enterprises already using Mimecast’s email security. The tight integration reduces vendor sprawl, and the Teams archiving adds value for organisations that have moved collaboration beyond email.
Proofpoint Archive is an enterprise-scale archiving platform for email, social media, SMS, and collaboration data. Proofpoint offers both enterprise and essentials tiers, making the platform accessible to both large organisations and smaller businesses looking for cost-effective archiving with unlimited storage options. The essentials package bundles archiving alongside email encryption and email security, offering good value for smaller teams. We think Proofpoint Archive fits large enterprises with complex, multi-channel compliance requirements.
The data type coverage is extensive. Email, social media, SMS, and collaboration tools all feed into a single searchable archive. Geography-specific retention policies support multinational compliance. Intelligent search is included without per-query costs. The dashboard provides compliance visualisations for reporting. Multiple pricing levels and unlimited storage options are available across tiers.
Customers praise the search speed and user-friendly interface for day-to-day operations. Compliance officers appreciate the reporting capabilities. Proofpoint Essentials users highlight the value for money and ease of use. Something to be aware of is that role management via AD groups complicates permission auditing, and shared mailbox licensing adds significant cost at scale.
We think Proofpoint Archive fits large enterprises with complex, multi-channel compliance requirements. If you are archiving beyond just email and need geography-specific retention policies, Proofpoint covers that ground. Smaller teams should evaluate the Essentials tier for bundled value.
Smarsh Archive captures communications across 100+ digital channels for regulated organisations, serving top banks across North America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific. Smarsh offers two levels of email archiving, one aimed at smaller companies and one aimed at enterprises. It is a premium service, and Smarsh is particularly strong for organisations that need the most advanced archiving available, especially in financial services. We think Smarsh works well for regulated financial services firms needing broad channel coverage with active supervision.
Smarsh provides native capture across email, mobile, voice, IM, and web data, preserving content in native formats and categorising messages for compliance review. The built-in policy library supports surveillance and compliance workflows. SEC 17a-4 and FINRA compliance support is built in. Smooth onboarding with minimal disruption to daily operations is consistently highlighted.
Customers praise the smooth onboarding and implementation process. The policy library gets positive mentions for surveillance workflows, and the capture breadth across channels is noted as a differentiator. Something to be aware of is that the interface feels dated and less user-friendly than modern alternatives, and the platform occasionally hangs when loading alerts.
We think Smarsh works well for regulated financial services firms needing broad channel coverage with active supervision. If your compliance programme demands surveillance across 100+ channels with native format preservation, Smarsh delivers that depth.
Trustifi Cloud Email Archive bundles archiving with AI-powered email security, including threat protection and Data Loss Prevention. We think Trustifi fits organisations wanting email security and archiving from one vendor.
Trustifi archives emails with 256-bit AES encryption and redundancy across multiple data centres. Customisable retention policies and real-time search cover compliance basics. AI-driven DLP and account protection extend beyond passive archiving. Frequent feature releases show ongoing product investment.
Customers consistently rate support as exceptional, comparing it favourably to enterprise-level vendors. When issues arise requiring patches, turnaround is fast. Something to be aware of is that the admin console can overwhelm new administrators, and aggressive quarantine settings increase review workload.
We think Trustifi fits organisations wanting email security and archiving from one vendor. If you are evaluating both capabilities simultaneously, the bundled approach simplifies procurement and management.
On-premises and cloud archiving with simple management and eDiscovery.
Google Workspace integrated archiving with retention and legal hold.
Email archiving with granular search and retention policy controls.
Scalable email archiving with advanced analytics and compliance.
We assessed each platform across storage capacity, retention policy flexibility, eDiscovery capabilities, compliance framework coverage, deployment options, integration with email clients, multi-channel support, pricing models, and real-world customer feedback. Products were evaluated on how effectively they help organisations store, search, and retrieve email communications for compliance and legal purposes.
When selecting an email archiving solution, start with your compliance requirements. Regulated industries need platforms that map to specific frameworks like SEC, FINRA, HIPAA, or GDPR. Storage model matters; unlimited storage removes capacity planning, while per-user models can become expensive at scale. Consider whether you need email-only archiving or multi-channel capture across Teams, SMS, social media, and voice. eDiscovery capabilities are critical for legal teams; look for indexed search, legal hold, and export functionality. Integration with your existing email client, particularly Outlook and M365, affects user adoption. Deployment model (cloud, on-premises, or hybrid) matters for organisations with specific data residency requirements. Finally, evaluate the migration path, both into and out of the platform, as switching archiving vendors involves moving large volumes of data.
Email archiving has evolved from simple storage into a compliance and legal necessity. Modern platforms now capture communications across dozens of channels, apply AI-powered search and surveillance, and support regulatory frameworks spanning multiple jurisdictions. The right choice depends on your compliance requirements, existing infrastructure, and the breadth of communications you need to archive. Organisations already running Microsoft 365 have a native option that covers basic needs at no additional cost. Regulated industries should prioritise platforms with specific framework support and immutable storage. MSPs and multi-tenant environments benefit from platforms with flexible admin consoles and competitive per-tenant pricing. For organisations evaluating archiving alongside email security, bundled platforms reduce vendor sprawl and simplify management.
Email archiving is the system of storing your email communication so they can later be retrieved, typically for legal and auditing purposes.
Email archiving solutions allow you to store tamper-proof, immutable copies of each and every email your organization sends and receives. Most email archiving solutions capture email content directly from the email client itself, or during transport, so the entire process occurs without any added work for IT teams or end users. These emails are stored separately to your main email client so that if you change company email systems, delete every email in your inbox, or your company network is wiped, you’ll still have copies of all your original emails.
Many email archives today are cloud-based, allowing you to access your stored emails from any device, at any time. They often also include e-discovery features, which allow you to search the archive for specific emails by attributes such as recipient, sender, time, attachment type, and subject.
Once you have found the emails you are looking for, or even if you need to bulk export every email from a particular month for example, archiving solutions make it easy to restore past emails and attachments.
Typically, third-party email archiving solutions work via the process journaling. Email journaling records all communications within the email archiving solution. The journaling system creates copies of all email messages and stores them in a secure, searchable database. This process can be customized based on your organization’s specific journaling and retention policies.
When deploying an email archiving solution to your email environment, for example Microsoft 365, you need to add a journaling rule in the admin center, which tells your email provider (e.g., Microsoft) to send emails to your chosen archiving database. Most email archiving solutions provide an in-depth guide to deployment based on specific steps required.
However, there are many different approaches to email archiving, and the specifics of how email archiving works can differ based on the approach used. Many users will be familiar with the email archiving functionality offered natively within Microsoft Outlook or Google Mail, in which archived emails are sent to a separate Archive folder. But this use case is meant for end-users to manage their emails more effectively, not for IT departments or compliance use cases.
When an end-user archives an email in Outlook or Google Mail, it is removed from their inbox and placed in a separate folder. From there, archived emails can be deleted or moved back to the inbox. Without an additional third-party email archiving solution, this does not ensure archived messages are kept secure and immutable.
When using an enterprise email archiving solution, a copy of every single inbound, outbound, or internal email is stored in a secure repository, where emails can be searched, placed on legal hold, and recovered. Meta-data and attachments can also be viewed.
This repository is usually cloud-based and accessible by admins, auditors, and legal compliance teams. Sometimes the cloud-archive can also be accessed by end-users, who can use the service to search through their own archive and view messages that have been lost or accidentally deleted.
There are several reasons that organizations should archive emails, particularly those in heavily regulated industries such as legal services, healthcare, government, and finance.
Common reasons for implementing email archiving tools include:
Email archiving solutions should be optimized for easy deployment, hands-off management, and fast search and retrieval when required. Key features to look for in an email archiving solution include:
The most common use case for email archiving solutions is to ensure compliance with auditing and data regulation requirements. As such, ensuring the solution you choose enables full legal compliance should be the first and most important feature that you consider.
This should include ensuring that all emails are automatically archived, along with attachments and meta-data that outlines where the email was sent, at what time, and to whom. It should also include details on replies, email chains and forwarding.
Archived emails should also be fully immutable. Nobody should be able to edit or tamper with archived data; this is an important stipulation in many legal regulations.
Compliance also means auditing who has access to the email archive. The best archiving solutions will provide granular permissions management with auditing over when the archive has been accessed.
Another important part of ensuring legal compliance is ensuring the archived data itself has tight security controls. Archived emails should be fully encrypted to ensure malicious threat actors are not able to compromise any sensitive information that may be held in email records.
We recommend looking for a system that protects archived emails when in transit and at rest. Proofpoint recommends that any data centers used to house cloud archived emails should be SSAE-16 SOC 2 Type II certified.
In addition, there should also be strong security controls to govern who has access to the archive. As previously mentioned, look for a solution with granular permissions management for accessing the archive, with comprehensive auditing. We also recommend that any access to the archive is reinforced with comprehensive multi-factor authentication.
Finally, we also recommend looking for a solution that has multiple layers of backup in different file formats. When storing backups of any type of data, you should follow the rule of “3 2 1”: store at least three copies of your data in two different locations, and at least one copy should be in a different format or medium to the others.
This means if one archive is corrupted or lost, you can easily recover data by switching to another backup method. Each one of these should again be secured with high levels of data security.
Arguably the most important feature on this list is the ability for auditors, admins or even end-users to be able to easily search the email archive to find data when needed. It’s great to have a legally compliant platform with excellent data security, but if the platform is impossible to use to actually find and export data when needed, the platform has failed.
So, a key feature to look out for is a well-designed user interface that should be simple to navigate and quick to return search results. A system that takes hours to search through an archive is not scalable for organizations that need to retain data over a period of years.
But as well as being simple to use, a good archiving platform will have comprehensive e-discovery functionality to return the results you actually want to see. You should be able to search on granular pre-defined filters, such as sender, recipient, date, and subject line. You should also be able to easily export particular emails and chains when needed, without having to go through a costly or time-consuming process.
This in and of itself is important also to the compliance use case. If auditors are unable to use an archiving system to find any emails related to a litigation case, for example, then it’s possible you could breach compliance regulations.
In addition, the e-discovery archive should also be available even when your email network is down. This is important in ensuring business continuity, giving users access to their inbox at all times.
There are many ways that email archiving can be deployed across an organization, but for most businesses we recommend looking for a cloud-based email archiving solution.
Most organizations today use cloud-based email platforms such as Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace; cloud-based email archiving solutions can integrate natively with these platforms, speeding up the deployment process and saving businesses valuable time.
In addition, cloud-based archiving can also be more cost effective and reliable, with fewer outages and downtime than legacy on-premises alternatives. Storage costs can also be lower with cloud-based solutions, and cloud-storage is often more scalable.
However, some organizations may be already using an on-premises email archiving solution but looking to move to the cloud. In this case, we recommend looking for a cloud-based provider with low costs for important legacy data, or using a hybrid email archiving approach, choosing a provider that offers both an on-premises and cloud-based solution.
Some organizations may also need file archiving alongside email archiving; in this instance, we recommend looking for an email archiving solution that also offers file and data archiving.
Legal hold is an important factor to consider when choosing an email archiving provider. This is the process of storing emails in anticipation of them being used in a litigation event or audit. It’s important that whichever email archiving solution you choose offers legal hold, covering the period of time you need.
Flexibility more broadly is an important aspect of email archiving. It’s important to choose a flexible service that stores emails for as long as you need them––we recommend a minimum of ten years––but many businesses will need to archive important emails for far longer.
However, over such a period of time, storage costs can become expensive, especially for organizations heavily reliant on email. For this reason, it’s a good idea to look for a service that only stores certain important emails long term, rather than spam messages like newsletters. Less important, external emails may only need to be archived for short periods of time, perhaps 12 months.
The best recommendation we can give for this particular point is to consider all the storage costs associated, along with your organizations’ particular use cases and compliance requirements, and look for a service flexible enough to meet your needs.
The final thing to look for in any archiving solution is the cost of importing and exporting data, and the archiving format. For many organizations email archiving represents a long-term commitment––this is not a solution you are likely to swap out on a regular basis.
For this reason, it’s a good idea to ensure that costs associated for migrating data into the archive, exporting data from the archive, and long-term storage costs are within your organization’s budget.
It’s also a good idea to check that the archiving provider you choose offers an open archiving format, so if for whatever reason you do need to export data into a different system, it’s not locked to a proprietary archiving system or data type.
Exporting data to a competitor’s archiving system can also have hidden costs, so it’s a good idea to thoroughly check the small print on any archiving solution you are considering.
When looking to implement an email archiving solution, organizations must build out a comprehensive strategy, outlining specific requirements such as retention policies and key data compliance regulations to follow. Combining this with the above features will help teams to ensure a successful email archiving deployment.
Joel is the Director of Content and a co-founder at Expert Insights; a rapidly growing media company focussed on covering cybersecurity solutions.
He’s an experienced journalist and editor with 8 years’ experience covering the cybersecurity space. He’s reviewed hundreds of cybersecurity solutions, interviewed hundreds of industry experts and produced dozens of industry reports read by thousands of CISOs and security professionals in topics like IAM, MFA, zero trust, email security, DevSecOps and more.
He also hosts the Expert Insights Podcast and co-writes the weekly newsletter, Decrypted. Joel is driven to share his team’s expertise with cybersecurity leaders to help them create more secure business foundations.
Craig MacAlpine is CEO and Founder of Expert Insights. Before founding Expert Insights in August 2018, Craig spent 10 years as CEO of EPA Cloud, an email security provider that rebranded as VIPRE Email Security following its acquisition by Ziff Davis, formerly J2Global (NASDAQ: ZD) in 2013.
Craig is a passionate security innovator with over 20 years of experience helping organizations to stay secure with cutting-edge information security and cybersecurity solutions.
Using his extensive experience in the email security industry, he founded Expert Insights with the singular goal of helping IT professionals and CISOs to cut through the noise and find the right cybersecurity solutions they need to protect their organizations.