IT Management

The Top 10 Columnar Databases

Columnar databases store and manage data in columns rather than rows, optimizing query performance and analytics processing, making them suitable for data warehousing and analytical workloads.

The Top 10 Columnar Databases include:
  • 1. Amazon Redshift
  • 2. Apache Druid
  • 3. Apache Kudu
  • 4. ClickHouse
  • 5. Google Cloud BigTable
  • 6. MariaDB
  • 7. Microsoft Azure Cosmos DB
  • 8. MonetDB
  • 9. OpenText Vertica
  • 10. Snowflake Data Cloud

Columnar databases, also known as column-oriented databases, provide a more efficient and optimized way of storing and querying data, particularly in big data and analytical environments. They store data in columns, rather than rows, which significantly improves query performance, reduces storage requirements, and optimizes data compression. The benefits of columnar databases are most evident when it comes to massive amounts of data that need to be searched, aggregated, or analyzed quickly. 

Columnar databases have become increasingly popular due to their ability to handle large-scale data warehouses and analytics workloads. In comparison to traditional row-based relational databases, columnar databases offer the advantage of improved query performance, especially for analytical functions, as well as more efficient data storage and compression techniques. They are particularly suitable for applications that require high-speed data retrieval and aggregation in near real-time.

The columnar database market has seen significant growth in recent years, with numerous providers delivering cutting-edge solutions. These databases have key features that include scalability, performance, data security, and ease of use, as well as their ability to integrate with existing infrastructure and analytics tools. In this guide, we will explore the top columnar databases on the market today, considering their strengths, weaknesses, and use cases, based on technical specifications, customer feedback, and industry trends. 

AWS Logo

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a leading cloud provider that offers over 200 fully-featured services from data centers worldwide. One of these services is Amazon Redshift, a data warehouse product designed for handling analytic workloads on big data sets by utilizing a column-oriented DBMS principle.

Amazon Redshift is a popular cloud data warehouse used by tens of thousands of customers to analyze exabytes of data and run complex analytical queries without the need to manage data warehouse infrastructure. This scalable service enables organizations to break through data silos, access near real-time information, and gain comprehensive predictive insights with no need to copy data. Redshift allows users to analyze structured and semi-structured data across data warehouses, operational databases, and data lakes using SQL. By utilizing AWS-designed hardware and machine learning, it delivers top-notch price performance at any scale. Key features of Amazon Redshift include automatically creating, training, and deploying machine learning models for predictive insights, securely sharing data between accounts and organizations, and easily connecting to third-party tools like Amazon QuickSight, Tableau, and Microsoft PowerBI – as well as other AWS services. The platform also offers automated backups and patching.

With simplified data access, users can conveniently interact with the platform, allowing them to focus on insights rather than infrastructure management.

AWS Logo
Druid Logo

Apache Druid is a high-performance real-time analytics database that specializes in delivering sub-second queries on both streaming and batch data at scale. It can efficiently execute OLAP queries on high-dimensional and high-cardinality datasets with billions to trillions of rows, without the need for predefined or cached queries. This makes it suitable for real-time analytics applications while utilizing less infrastructure compared to other databases.

Druid’s interactive query engine leverages scatter/gather methodology for high-speed queries by preloading data into memory or local storage to minimize data movement and network latency. The platform’s elastic architecture and loosely coupled components for ingestion, queries, and orchestration allow easy and quick scale-up and scale-out, while its automatic data services – which include continuous backup, automated recovery, and multi-node replication – ensure high availability and durability. Once ingested, data is automatically columnarized, time-indexed, dictionary-encoded, bitmap-indexed, and type-aware compressed. Druid also simplifies schema management with its schema auto-discovery feature that detects, defines, and updates column names and data types upon ingestion. The platform also offers SQL support for an easy-to-use and familiar interface for end-to-end data operations.

In summary, Apache Druid is a versatile, real-time analytics database designed for high performance, scalability, and consistency, providing businesses with the tools to efficiently process and analyze both streaming and historical data.

Druid Logo
Apache Kudu Logo

Apache Kudu is an open-source distributed data storage engine designed for fast analytics on constantly changing data. It organizes its data by column rather than row for efficient encoding and compression. Using techniques like run-length encoding, differential encoding, and vectorized bit-packing, Kudu delivers fast reading and efficient storage.

To accommodate large datasets and clusters, Kudu splits tables into smaller units called tablets, which can be configured based on hashing, range partitioning, or a combination of both. This enables a balance between parallelism for analytic workloads and high concurrency for online tasks. To ensure data safety and availability, Kudu uses the Raft consensus algorithm to replicate all operations for a given tablet, keeping data secure even if a machine fails. Its storage system is tailored for the IO characteristics of solid-state drives and includes an experimental cache implementation based on the libpmem library for persistent memory storage. The platform also offers in-process tracing capabilities, extensive metrics support, and watchdog threads that check for latency outliers and dump “smoking gun” stack traces to get to the root of the problem quickly.

Implemented in C++, Kudu can scale easily to accommodate large amounts of memory per node, and its highly concurrent key storage data structures enable the software to scale efficiently across numerous cores. By utilizing an in-memory columnar execution path and SIMD operations from the SSE4 and AVX instruction sets, Kudu achieves impressive instruction-level parallelism.

Apache Kudu Logo
Clickhouse Logo

ClickHouse is an open-source column-oriented database management system (DBMS) designed for online analytical processing (OLAP) and real-time analytical reporting using SQL queries. It focuses on query execution performance, user-friendliness, scalability, and security to serve as a dependable production system for a wide range of users worldwide.

ClickHouse offers a high level of reliability, ease of use, and fault tolerance. Being a column-oriented database, ClickHouse stores data in columns instead of rows, allowing it to process OLAP scenarios rapidly and effectively. By leveraging all available system resources, ClickHouse ensures that each analytical query is processed as quickly as possible. The platform is also highly scalable and flexible; it supports shared-nothing clusters as well as separation of storage and compute, and scales efficiently with hardware resources to petabyte scale.

ClickHouse is versatile and can operate in various environments, including personal machines and cloud-based systems. It’s also very user-friendly, enabling users to write queries with an SQL dialect. This adaptability ensures that users can take advantage of ClickHouse’s high-performance processing and analytical capabilities, regardless of their environment.

Clickhouse Logo
Google Cloud logo

Google Cloud Bigtable is a fully managed wide-column and key-value NoSQL database service designed for large analytical and operational workloads. This highly scalable solution provides the ability to store terabytes or petabytes of data within a sparsely populated table that can scale to billions of rows and thousands of columns.

Bigtable integrates smoothly with the Apache ecosystem of open-source big data software, thanks to its compatibility with various client libraries, including a supported extension to the Apache HBase library for Java. It offers several advantages over a self-managed HBase installation, such as incredible scalability, simple administration, and cluster resizing without downtime. This scalability eliminates the design bottleneck found in self-managed HBase installations and allows for better management of resources during times of increased load. It is ideal for applications requiring high throughput and scalability for key/value data, Bigtable can handle values up to 10 MB in size. It performs exceptionally in storing and querying time-series data, marketing data, financial data, Internet of Things data, and graph data.

Bigtable offers globally distributed and multi-region deployments. It has low latency and supports high read and write throughput, making it an ideal data source for MapReduce operations. Bigtable’s strengths make it an excellent storage engine for batch MapReduce operations, stream processing/analytics, and machine learning applications.

Google Cloud logo
MariaDB Logo

MariaDB is a cloud database company offering products for a wide range of businesses and use-cases. With over one billion downloads, MariaDB’s database products are used extensively through Linux distributions and boast both quick deployment and easy maintenance using cloud automation. They are designed to accommodate any workload, cloud, and scale.

MariaDB’s open-source column-based storage enables real-time analytics and delivers high-performing, scalable analytics using standard SQL. Traditional relational databases may struggle with performance when dealing with large transactional datasets, but MariaDB’s columnar databases allow for faster and easier analytical queries, while still maintaining the benefits of the relational model and SQL. This approach simplifies database infrastructure for modern analytics by scaling to accommodate massive amounts of data, utilizing high-performance streaming data adapters, providing significant compression rates, and supporting standard SQL with near-real-time latency. The solution also offers in-built security features, including user authentication and encryption.

The flexibility of MariaDB allows for on-demand analytics without the need for complex ETL processes or specialized databases. It enables interactive, real-time queries using standard SQL, eliminating the need for data models and indexes optimized for predetermined queries. Overall, MariaDB offers a modern, on-demand analytics solution at scale that delivers deep insights quickly, without requiring proprietary Big Data appliances.

MariaDB Logo
Azure logo

Microsoft Azure Cosmos DB is a comprehensive database service designed for modern app development, with applications in AI, digital commerce, Internet of Things, and booking management. As a fully managed NoSQL and relational database, it ensures quick response times, automatic scalability and speed, and SLA-backed availability with robust security measures.

Azure Cosmos DB streamlines app development with its turnkey multi-region data distribution, open-source APIs, SDKs for popular languages, and AI database functionalities, such as native vector search and seamless integration with Azure AI Services. As a fully managed service, it takes database administration out of users’ hands, handling automatic updates and patching as well as providing cost-effective serverless and automatic scaling. Focusing on simplified application development, Azure Cosmos DB offers a variety of features including open-source APIs, multiple SDKs, schemaless data, and no-ETL analytics over operational data.

It is mission-critical ready, ensuring business continuity, 99.999% availability, and enterprise-level security. Azure Cosmos DB for PostgreSQL supports append-only columnar table storage for analytic and data warehousing workloads, enhancing data compression and query efficiency. Overall, this is a strong solution for organizations that would benefit from the global availability of Azure.

Azure logo

MonetDB Solutions is a technical consulting company founded in 2013, specializing in database technologies for Business Intelligence, Analytics, and Big Data. The founders created MonetDB, an open-source column-store database management system known for its maturity and widespread use. MonetDB has been in development since 1993, focusing on high-performance data warehouses, business intelligence, and eScience applications.

MonetDB offers innovations in storage models, query execution architecture, automatic and adaptive indices, run-time query optimization, and modular software architecture. The system is fully ACID compliant and supports various programming interfaces, such as JDBC, ODBC, PHP, Python, RoR, C/C++, and Perl. MonetDB is available as a source tarball, packaged installations, and binary installers compatible with various platforms. A regular release schedule ensures timely access to new improvements. The MonetDB system offers frequent updates and third-party additions, is highly customizable, and can be adapted for different applications thanks to its three-level software stack. It includes tactical optimizers, a columnar abstract-machine kernel, and an SQL-compliant database front-end, which allows it to support use cases from pure analytics to hybrid transactional and analytical processing.

MonetDB comes with several linked-in libraries that provide functionality for various data types and user-defined functions. It’s distributed under a liberal open-source license, allowing users to modify and redistribute the system as needed.

OpenText Logo

Vertica, developed by OpenText, is a high-performance analytical database designed to handle complex data analytics at any scale and in various locations. This columnar, relational database is ANSI-Standard SQL and ACID-compliant, catering to the needs of businesses with demanding analytics use cases.

Efficient in operation, Vertica minimizes storage and compute costs by optimizing resource usage through its Massively Parallel Processing (MPP) capabilities. This feature enables the running of queries 10-50 times faster, performing them in parallel across multiple nodes or instances, thus providing high concurrency and low latency. Featuring over 650 in-database analytics that are available in SQL, R, and Python, Vertica supports various functions including time series, event pattern matching, geospatial, and in-database machine learning. Additionally, it expands your data lakehouse capabilities with semi-structured data support, schema on read, streaming data, and external queries on data lake formats like Parquet and ORC. In terms of security, Vertica encrypts data in motion and while stored in the database. The platform also offers in-database machine learning, which users can utilize to personalize the platform, as well as monitor and automate the operation of their microservices architectures.

As an infrastructure-agnostic and software-only solution, Vertica can be deployed on-premises, in private clouds using object stores, as a containerized solution, in any public cloud, or even as a hybrid setup. Vertica Accelerator also offers a data warehouse managed service on AWS, with future expansion to other cloud platforms.

OpenText Logo
Snowflake Logo

Snowflake is a data management solution that offers the Data Cloud, a global network that enables thousands of organizations to streamline their data operations with scale, concurrency, and performance. By consolidating siloed data, facilitating secure data sharing, and supporting diverse analytic workloads, Snowflake provides a seamless experience across multiple public clouds, including AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud.

The Data Cloud is powered by Snowflake’s single platform, which features a unique cloud-based architecture that connects businesses on a global scale and promotes data integration. With the Snowflake Marketplace, users can easily share, collaborate on, and monetize datasets, services, and data applications, contributing to the growth of the Data Cloud. Snowflake’s platform eradicates data silos and streamlines architectures, making it simpler for organizations to extract value from their data. Designed as a unified product, the platform is optimized for performance at scale and supports various workloads and languages, including SQL, Python, and Java. The platform also provides a consistent experience across multiple regions and clouds, facilitating data access, governance, and collaboration. Finally, with the platform’s Cortex AI feature, users can run natural language processing or generate custom summaries using LLMs such as Snowflake Arctic, Mistral Large, and Llama 3, and deliver both structured and unstructured data to their teams via conversational interfaces.

Users can deploy the Data Cloud either using native development interfaces, using their own IDE, or using a third-party tool. With Snowflake, users can accelerate AI and machine learning workflows, develop and scale data-intensive applications, enhance cybersecurity, collaborate effectively, and deploy flexible data warehouse and data lake architectural patterns with streamlined governance and storage.

Snowflake Logo
The Top 10 Columnar Databases - Expert Insights